- Research article
- Open Access
Fine mapping of a linkage peak with integration of lipid traits identifies novel coronary artery disease genes on chromosome 5
BMC Genetics volume 13, Article number: 12 (2012)
Coronary artery disease (CAD), and one of its intermediate risk factors, dyslipidemia, possess a demonstrable genetic component, although the genetic architecture is incompletely defined. We previously reported a linkage peak on chromosome 5q31-33 for early-onset CAD where the strength of evidence for linkage was increased in families with higher mean low density lipoprotein-cholesterol (LDL-C). Therefore, we sought to fine-map the peak using association mapping of LDL-C as an intermediate disease-related trait to further define the etiology of this linkage peak. The study populations consisted of 1908 individuals from the CATHGEN biorepository of patients undergoing cardiac catheterization; 254 families (N = 827 individuals) from the GENECARD familial study of early-onset CAD; and 162 aorta samples harvested from deceased donors. Linkage disequilibrium-tagged SNPs were selected with an average of one SNP per 20 kb for 126.6-160.2 MB (region of highest linkage) and less dense spacing (one SNP per 50 kb) for the flanking regions (117.7-126.6 and 160.2-167.5 MB) and genotyped on all samples using a custom Illumina array. Association analysis of each SNP with LDL-C was performed using multivariable linear regression (CATHGEN) and the quantitative trait transmission disequilibrium test (QTDT; GENECARD). SNPs associated with the intermediate quantitative trait, LDL-C, were then assessed for association with CAD (i.e., a qualitative phenotype) using linkage and association in the presence of linkage (APL; GENECARD) and logistic regression (CATHGEN and aortas).
We identified four genes with SNPs that showed the strongest and most consistent associations with LDL-C and CAD: EBF1, PPP2R2B, SPOCK1, and PRELID2. The most significant results for association of SNPs with LDL-C were: EBF1, rs6865969, p = 0.01; PPP2R2B, rs2125443, p = 0.005; SPOCK1, rs17600115, p = 0.003; and PRELID2, rs10074645, p = 0.0002). The most significant results for CAD were EBF1, rs6865969, p = 0.007; PPP2R2B, rs7736604, p = 0.0003; SPOCK1, rs17170899, p = 0.004; and PRELID2, rs7713855, p = 0.003.
Using an intermediate disease-related quantitative trait of LDL-C we have identified four novel CAD genes, EBF1, PRELID2, SPOCK1, and PPP2R2B. These four genes should be further examined in future functional studies as candidate susceptibility loci for cardiovascular disease mediated through LDL-cholesterol pathways.
Coronary artery disease (CAD) is the end result of accumulation of atheromatous plaques in the coronary arteries, leading to eventual impairment of cardiac blood flow and potentially devastating consequences of myocardial infarction (MI) or death. CAD is the leading cause of death in both the United States and worldwide, with over 500,000 deaths per year in the U.S. and over seven million worldwide (World Health Organization) . Despite the development of pharmacologic therapies for prevention, the incidence of CAD is increasing, concomitant with the rising prevalence of risk factors such as obesity and diabetes (American Heart Association) .
CAD itself is clearly a heritable trait, with the role of genetic factors becoming increasingly apparent in early-onset CAD [3–5]. However, the genetic architecture of CAD, as with many common diseases, is assumed to be complex and continues to be poorly understood. Candidate gene studies have identified several loci for CAD, but with inconsistent results in validation cohorts. Recent genome wide association studies (GWAS) have consistently identified a locus on chromosome 9p21; however, this locus confers only modest risk of disease with effect sizes of 1.3-1.6 . Thus, much of the genetic architecture underlying the heritability of CAD remains to be elucidated. There are many well-established risk factors for CAD that are partitioned between extrinsic (smoking, sedentary lifestyle, poor nutrition) and intrinsic (sex, age, lipid levels, hypertension) factors, each of which may have underlying genetic components, making it difficult to divide CAD risk into genetic and non-genetic factors. However, using these intermediate disease-related intrinsic factors as genetic traits may help to identify novel CAD genetic loci.
We have previously reported a genome-wide linkage scan for early-onset CAD using the GENECARD family-based cohort, which identified nine genomic regions linked to CAD . The 1q and 3q regions have been fine-mapped and the susceptibility genes identified (including FAM5C and KALIRN, respectively) [8, 9]. The signal for 5q31 was present in the overall sample and was not unique to any one phenotypic subset. However, using ordered subset analysis (OSA) to dissect genetic heterogeneity and using lipid levels as quantitative traits, we found that the evidence for linkage on chromosome 5q was increased in families with higher mean total and low density lipoprotein-cholesterol (LDL-C) .
Rather than focusing on disease status alone as the trait of interest using one analytic technique, one can apply multiple methods to CAD and disease-related traits within one genomic region, thereby exploring the solution space of the combined analyses and identifying overlapping results; such results act as an internal replication and increase the likelihood that the genetic variant is truly involved in the pathogenesis of CAD. Recently Williams and Haines argued that the replication standard is a strong indicator of a true genetic effect and possibly preferable to the p-value standard .
Thus, we report herein our work to fine-map the CAD susceptibility locus on chromosome 5q31, using association analyses of quantitative (LDL-C) and qualitative (CAD and atherosclerosis) traits, using the quantitative results to prioritize the results obtained from qualitative analyses. We conducted this study in several relatively large and independent CAD cohorts, including 1908 individuals from a cohort of patients undergoing cardiac catheterization (CATHGEN), 827 individuals from a family-based study of early-onset CAD (GENECARD) and 162 individuals from a repository of aortic tissue collected from deceased donors. Using this approach of analyses performed in parallel, we identified four genes on chromosome 5q31-33 (SPOCK1, PPP2R2B, PRELID2, and EBF1) as candidate susceptibility genes for CAD mediated through LDL-C.
All subjects signed a current informed consent form and these studies were approved by the institutional review boards of each participating center.
GENECARD family-based study of early-onset CAD
Genetics of Early Onset Cardiovascular Disease (GENECARD) is a multicenter family-based linkage study of early-onset CAD using an affected sibling pair based approach; study methods have been described . For GENECARD, early-onset CAD was defined as: MI or unstable angina, coronary angiography showing at least 50% stenosis in a major vessel, revascularization procedure as either percutaneous coronary intervention or coronary artery bypass graft, or a functional test showing reversible myocardial ischemia, occurring before the age of 51 in men and before the age of 56 in women. Of the 438 families included in the original linkage study , we selected 254 families, including 726 individuals (504 affected and 222 unaffected) for analysis of cardiovascular endpoints. These families were selected based on the availability of an unaffected family member to maximize power for association analyses (151 families). In addition, families identified from OSA  that contributed to the linkage peak on chromosome 5 were also included (103 families). For the analysis of LDL cholesterol traits, 827 individuals from these 254 families were used. LDL-C values were either extracted from medical records or directly measured using the Boehringer Manheim cholesterol enzymatic kit (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN, USA) as previously detailed . Given that LDL-C measurements derived from medical records were estimated using the Friedewald equation , any individual with triglyceride levels greater than 400 mg/dL were coded as missing for LDL-C. LDL-C measurements greater than four standard deviations from the mean were coded as missing in order to exclude undue influences of extreme outliers.
CATHGEN non-familial cohort
The CATHGEN biorepository consists of sequential individuals recruited through the cardiac catheterization laboratory at Duke University Hospital (Durham, NC). Case-control status in the CATHGEN sample was assigned as a function of coronary artery disease index (CADi) and age, such that controls had reached a sufficient age to be at risk of developing disease . All CATHGEN subjects fasted for a minimum of seven hours prior to blood sample collection. Blood was collected via the femoral artery and processed immediately for collection of plasma, and then frozen within hours at -80°C. For this study, we selected 1908 CATHGEN subjects based on their CAD status as previously used for genetic analyses . We had two sources of LDL-C levels; derived from the medical records for a subset of the participants; and lipoprotein particle number concentration measured in stored, frozen, fasting plasma by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy through Liposcience (Liposcience, Raleigh, NC, USA), using published techniques [13, 14]. For quantitative trait analyses, total LDL particle number (LDLP) was used as a surrogate for LDL-C; in those CATHGEN individuals for whom both LDL-C and LDLP levels were available (N = 669), the two measures were strongly correlated (r = 0.67, p < 0.0001). Leptin levels were available for 380 individuals from the CATHGEN sample, as previously reported [10, 15]
Human Aorta Tissue Collection
A collection of 162 aortas were harvested from deceased donors and prepared as previously described . DNA was extracted from the tissue for genotyping using standard protocols. In addition, histopathological studies of the aortas were performed. Specifically, samples were assessed for extent of early atherosclerotic lesions with Sudan IV staining and severe disease assessed by the extent of raised lesions. The burden of atherosclerosis in the aortas was measured using the protocol described in the Pathobiological Determinants of Atherosclerosis in the Young study (PDAY) and were given a graded score (1-4) . As these aortas were harvested from deceased donors, the clinical information attached to each sample was limited, consisting of sex, age, and race.
SNPs were selected for genotyping based on both the physical distance between SNPs (density dependent selection) and based on the pattern of linkage disequilibrium (LD) within the region (tagging SNPs). SNP map positions and gene identities were derived from the most recent draft of the human genome available (GRCh37/hg19). Within the region of highest lod scores, the average SNP spacing was 1 per 20 kb. Within the flanking genomic regions, SNPs were selected for an average density of 1 per 50 kb. In addition tagging SNPs were selected to capture LD information within coding regions using HapMap data and the Tagger algorithm with the following criteria: an r-squared greater than or equal to 0.7 and a minor allele frequency (MAF) greater than or equal to 0.05; LD between SNPs was visualized using Haploview . One SNP was chosen for each LD bin. Priority was given to coding SNPs, followed by SNPs within known regulatory regions, intronic SNPs, and SNPs located within the 5' or 3' UTR, resulting in a list of 744 haplotype tagging SNPs with one SNP per LD bin. Finally, any SNPs with an Illumina score of less than 0.6, a MAF of less than 0.05, or coded as a potential failure by the Illumina software were excluded from the selection. The final list contained 2,256 SNPs, composed of both density-dependent (1,512) and tagging (744) SNPs.
Genomic DNA from the GENECARD and CATHGEN samples was extracted from whole blood using the PureGene system (Gentra Systems, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA). SNPs were genotyped in two rounds, initially at the Center for Human Genetics at Duke University and subsequently through the NHLBI funded Seattle SNPs (http://pga.gs.washington.edu). The genotyping was performed using the Illumina GoldenGate technology (San Diego, CA, USA). To ensure genotyping accuracy and reliability, several quality control methods were used including two HapMap CEPH individuals and two duplicate individuals included per 96-well plate. SNPs with call rates less than 95% (N = 174) were excluded and individuals with a less than 90% genotyping rate were excluded (N = 57), resulting in 2082 SNPs on a total of 2823 individuals available for analysis. Of those, 20 deviated significantly from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) in Caucasians (p < 0.001) . These 20 SNPs were analyzed, as it has been shown that some deviations from HWE are consistent with reasonable models for complex disease . However, none of these 20 SNPs was significant in any of the analyses performed and had no impact on the reported results.
Association with Quantitative LDL-cholesterol Traits
In the GENECARD sample, association between each individual SNP with LDL-C was performed using the quantitative disequilibrium test (QTDT)  and a linear model. Of the available GENECARD sample, an average of 122 trios was analyzed per marker (range 30-196, median 130). In the CATHGEN sample, genotypic and allelic associations between each individual SNP and LDLP were assessed using multivariable logistic regression adjusted for race, age, and sex. Given the low power for association in the GENECARD study, we chose to combine the quantitative analysis results for each SNP from GENECARD and CATHGEN using Fisher's method for combining p-values. Given previous reports that one of our identified genes (EBF1) is associated with decreased leptin levels in a murine knockout model , we used the Wilcoxon rank sum test to test for association of SNPs within and flanking EBF1 with leptin levels in those CATHGEN individuals with available leptin data (N = 380).
Association/Linkage Analysis with Cardiovascular Disease
The total SNP panel was tested for association with CAD in GENECARD and CATHGEN and with atherosclerosis in the aorta samples. In the GENECARD study, parametric two-point linkage for early-onset CAD was performed with a recessive (at risk allele freq 0.20, and penetrance 0.001) and dominant (at risk allele freq 0.01, and penetrance 0.001) model using Vitesse  and Homog . These tests were conducted to provide independent validation of SNPs showing evidence for association. In the presence of association and linkage, there tends to be a positive correlation between tests of association and linkage; however, there is no such correlation between tests when linkage and association are not present, implying that true positive results in one test tend to be reflected by positive results in another . Family based association with early onset CAD was performed using the association in the presence of linkage test (APL) . This test appropriately accounts for the non-independence of affected siblings and calculates a robust estimate of the genetic variance.
In the CATHGEN cohort, we used multivariable logistic regression adjusted for race and sex, using allelic and genotypic models to test for association with CAD case-control status. In addition, a second CAD case-control series was constructed using the subset of the GENECARD probands (N = 150) that were sampled from North America to more closely resemble the CATHGEN controls (N = 400), as we have previously done ; in these analyses, logistic regression was used to test for association between individual SNPs and CAD adjusted for race and sex.
In the aorta sample, the qualitative phenotype was atherosclerosis status, defined by a histopathologic index of atherosclerosis , which was analyzed via multivariable linear regression, with adjustments for race and sex under genotypic and allelic models. For all analyses, any results with a nominal p-value ≤ 0.05 were considered to be significant. We did not specifically adjust for multiple comparisons, as our method of comparing multiple related analyses in independent datasets, which we refer to as analyses in parallel, provides internal replication for significant results in the same gene in multiple analyses and further support the significance of the initial observation. Analyses were conducted using SAS Version 9.1 (Cary, NC) unless otherwise specified for specific statistical analysis programs (i.e. QTDT, APL and linkage).
Quantitative Trait Associations for LDL-cholesterol Traits
The baseline characteristics of the overall study populations have been reported . LDL-C measurements were available for 827 individuals in the GENECARD cohort, with a mean LDL-C concentration of 127.1 mg/dL (standard deviation [SD] 52.3 mg/dL). Family-based association resulted in 32 SNPs in 17 distinct genes that were significantly associated with LDL-C (Additional File 1 Table S1), with the four most significant SNPs residing in the gene PRELID2 , (PRELI domain containing 2 isoform) (rs10074645, rs6893183, rs17103583, and rs1865009, p = 0.0002-0.002), which were all in linkage disequilibrium with each other (D' ranging from 0.85-0.95). In the CATHGEN cohort (N = 1,908), mean LDLP levels were 1,131 nmol/L (SD 413 nmol/L). In CATHGEN, we found 102 SNPs in 46 distinct genes that were significantly associated with LDLP levels (Additional File 2 Table S1), with the most significant findings for SNPs in the genes SPOCK1 (sparc/osteonectin, cwcv and kazal-like domains) (rs17600115, p = 0.003) and PPP2R2B (phosphatase 2 regulatory subunit B family) (rs2125443, p = 0.005). Given low power for association in the GENECARD study, the p-values from the GENECARD and CATHGEN studies were combined using Fisher's method, resulting in 51 SNPs with combined p-values ≤ 0.05 (Table 1). As such, we found ten genes with significant results for association with LDL-C phenotypes in both the GENECARD and CATHGEN cohorts, with the strongest, most consistent results for SNPs in PRELID2, SPOCK1, PPP2R2B, and EBF1 (Early B-Cell Factor 1). The results for the quantitative analyses with LDL-C traits are summarized in Figure 1.
Given previous studies showing that mouse knockout models for EBF1 have reduced leptin levels , we also tested all EBF1 SNPs and SNPs upstream and downstream of EBF1 (N = 78 SNPs) for association with leptin levels (median 13.8 micrograms/L, range 0.4-104.9 micrograms/L) in a subset of CATHGEN (N = 380); six EBF1 SNPs were nominally significantly associated with leptin levels (Additional File 3 Table S1). The most significant result was for rs13165442 (p = 0.001), however that SNP was not significant for association with lipid levels or CAD. The SNP rs17635991 in EBF1, however, was nominally associated with CAD (p = 0.02) and with leptin levels (p = 0.03).
Qualitative Trait Association with CAD/atherosclerosis
Those genes with significant results for association with LDL-C traits were retained for comparison to the CAD endpoint results; only those genes which had a significant result in at least one CAD endpoint were retained for analysis. This list was further reduced by selecting those genes with the lowest p-values and the most consistent results across all analyses (i.e. significant results for the largest number of independent tests).
In the GENECARD sample, 102 SNPs in 45 distinct genes were significantly associated with CAD using APL (Additional File 4 Table S1); the most significant results were SNPs in the genes PPP2R2B (rs7736604, p = 0.0003) and SPOCK1 (rs17170899, p = 0.003). Two-point linkage analysis in GENECARD resulted in 16 SNPs in seven genes with LOD scores ≥ 1.5 at θ = 0, with the highest LOD scores of 2.1 obtained for two SNPs (rs17166444 in the FSTL4 (follistatin-like 4 precursor) and rs7736046 in PRELID2) (Additional File 5 Table S1) and evidence for linkage at both SPOCK1 (rs1919515, LOD = 1.8) and PRELID2 (rs7736046, LOD = 2.1).
In the CATHGEN sample, we found 178 SNPs in 58 genes that were associated with CAD (Additional File 6 Table S1) with the most significant results for an intergenic SNP (rs10050603, p = 0.0002) 628 kb distal to EBF1. In addition, there were significant results for PPP2R2B (rs1383169, p = 0.009), PRELID2 (rs7713855, p = 0.003), SPOCK1 (rs6872714, p = 0.02), and EBF1 (rs6865969, p = 0.007). The GENECARD proband-CATHGEN case/control validation cohort analysis resulted in 132 significant SNPs in 60 distinct genes (Additional File 7 Table S1), with the most significant evidence for association with CAD for SNPs in ARAP3 (ArfGAP with RhoGAP domain, ankyrin repeat and PH) (rs6895094, p = 0.0001) and the transcript CTB-99A3.1 (rs11744339, p = 0.0003), which overlaps the genomic location of PPP2R2B. In addition, the genes EBF1 (rs17712788, p = 0.007), PPP2R2B (rs1383169, p = 0.01), and SPOCK1 (rs6884385, p = 0.01) also had significant associations. In the aorta samples, we found 165 SNPs in 49 genes (Additional File 8 Table S1) that were significantly associated with the degree of atherosclerosis. The most significant association was with a SNP in the gene ATPase, class V, type 10B (ATP10B (; rs1990889, p = 0.001). The genes SPOCK1 (rs2043478, p = 0.008), PPP2R2B (rs1383167, p = 0.02), and EBF1 (rs6865969, p = 0.02) also contained significantly associated SNPs. All of the qualitative results for association with CAD or degree of atherosclerosis are summarized in Figure 2.
Analyses in Parallel
Of the 51 SNPs in ten genes that were significantly associated with LDL-C traits, we further reduced this list of candidates by selecting only those genes which had at least one significant association with any of the CAD endpoints, resulting in a list of nine genes (Figure 3). These genes were then prioritized by both the size of the p-value and consistency in effect across both quantitative and qualitative analyses. This selection resulted in a final list of four genes (Table 2) with the most consistent association with LDL-C traits and CAD/atherosclerosis, although with varying effects for SNPs within those genes. The LD pattern for significant SNPs within each gene showed few examples of strong LD between significant SNPs (Additional Files 9, 10, 11 and 12), with the exception of PRELID2 (Additional File 12). In order to verify the independence of these four loci, pairwise LD was calculated for all SNPs across the four genes; there was no LD between SNPs from differing genes (data not shown).
We have demonstrated herein that disease-related intermediate traits can identify novel disease risk genes. Specifically, we used LDL-cholesterol traits to fine-map a linkage peak on chromosome 5 from the GENECARD study of early-onset CAD with integration of these results with association and linkage to cardiovascular disease. Using this approach, we have identified four candidate genes (EBF1, PPP2R2B, PRELID2, and SPOCK1) that may represent novel cardiovascular disease risk genes mediated through LDL cholesterol pathways.
Although no genome scans for CAD or MI have reported linkage to this region, there are several potentially related phenotypes that have been mapped to the 5q31 locus including inflammatory or autoimmune conditions (celiac disease , asthma , Grave's disease , psoriasis , and Crohn disease ) as well as cardiac and vascular phenotypes (cardiomyopathy , intracranial aneurysm , infantile hemangioma , and systolic and diastolic blood pressures [35, 36]). Several GWAS and meta-analyses have been published for lipid related traits [37–40]. However, only one study has reported a significant association for any genes on chromosome 5q31-33, for the gene T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin domain containing 4 (TIMD4) , which is 1.7 Mb centromeric to EBF1 and 9.9 Mb telomeric to PPP2R2B. Nominally significant results were obtained for SNPs within TIMD4 and its ligand (HAVCR2), which is 152 kb telomeric to TIMD4 (Additional Files 2 Table S1, 6 Table S1, and 8 Table S1).
Using a database of publicly available GWAS results from NHGRI, we looked for any reports of significant associations for SNPs within the 1 lod interval on chromosome 5. There are few references to cardiovascular disease or disease-related traits. However, none of these SNPs overlap with significant SNPs in our results, with the exception of two studies of hypertension/systolic blood pressure [41, 42], each of which reported one significant association with a SNP in EBF1; unfortunately, neither of those two SNPs was examined in our study.
The gene EBF1 is involved in hematopoiesis and immunity . Interestingly, studies of knockout mice have identified a role for EBF1 in metabolism , a cardiovascular disease related phenotype. The null mice described by Fretz et al. have a unique metabolic syndrome characterized by lipodystrophy, hypotryglyceridemia, and hypoglycemia, while having an increased metabolic rate and decreased leptin levels. The mouse lipodystrophy is characterized by an increase in yellow adipose tissue in bone marrow and a marked decrease in white adipose tissue (by as much as 90%), relative to wild type controls. These findings are consistent with EBF1's regulation of adipocyte progenitors [44, 45]. In our study, SNPs in EBF1 were significantly associated with LDL cholesterol traits and the CAD endpoints, with the exception of two-point linkage. In addition, EBF1 variation was associated with leptin levels in our sample, although the results for individual SNPs were inconsistent with their association with lipids and CAD endpoints. This may suggest that EBF1 has a similar role in regulating adiposity and lipid metabolism in humans, and that variants in the gene may represent good candidate polymorphisms for cardiovascular disease and dyslipidemia in humans.
Of the other candidate genes identified, SPOCK1 is associated with age at menarche via a genome-wide association study [46, 47]. SPOCK1 encodes a proteoglycan that functions as a protease inhibitor; although initially identified in testes , it is expressed in many human tissues including blood. SNPs within SPOCK1 were tested for sex-specific effects in our sample via a stratified analysis; no significant sex effects were observed (data not shown). PPP2R2B encodes a brain specific regulatory subunit of a protein phosphatase and is the causal locus for a Mendelian disease, a form of spinocerebellar ataxia (SCA12, OMIM# 604326). Little is known about the function of the gene PRELID2 other than it contains a 'prel-like domain,' from which its name is derived.
Using a strategy of analyses in parallel we have identified four novel candidate genes for cardiovascular disease. The ability to reduce the list of potential candidates within the linkage region on chromosome 5q31-33 from a few hundred to only four is proof of principle that this strategy may be a useful tool for analyzing complex traits. In addition, had we relied upon CAD endpoint analyses alone, we would have obtained less significant associations overall and would have prioritized a different set of candidate genes. One of the major strengths of our study is the detailed phenotype information available for both the GENECARD cohort and CATHGEN biorepository. The rigorous inclusion criteria and case definitions used in GENECARD and CATHGEN have led to objective measures for CAD endpoints, a phenotype that would otherwise have a subjective definition. In this particular study, direct sequencing, rather than SNP genotyping across multiple samples, would not have been appropriate; if we were to re-sequence a sub-set of the sample, it is not clear which individuals would be selected for such sequencing, particularly for the continuous quantitative traits we examine. Finally, our sample is of mixed ethnicity (Caucasian and African-American), which would necessitate a separate re-sequencing effort for each ethnicity.
This study has some limitations. First, all four genes may be CAD susceptibility genes and act independently (as the LD patterns in our samples suggest). However, it is possible that SNPs within our sample are in LD with causal SNPs at another locus and the association results from these four genes may not be independent. Second, we have focused on the consistency of the results at the gene level (i.e., which genes have SNPs that are significant in multiple analyses). However, it is not the case that the same SNPs are significant in those analyses or, in the case that the same SNP is significant, that the magnitude of that significance is similar between analyses. Thus, we cannot begin to identify individual SNPs within a candidate gene that are likely to be driving the results via direct or indirect biological action. This can be explained, in part, by the fact that the phenotypes, while correlated, are not perfectly correlated. Therefore, it is expected that there will be differences in the p-values for associations with different phenotypes and this could cause certain associations to fall outside the nominal p-value cutoff. Finally, the results were not interpreted in the context of correction for multiple comparisons. There are two main difficulties with applying such corrections to these results, i.e. a Bonferroni correction which would be overly conservative. First, the phenotypes examined are correlated, therefore the analyses conducted using more than one phenotype within the same sample are not independent. Second, if we look at the results sequentially, with one analysis conducted after another, then the prior probability that a given SNP in a gene of interest will be significant in subsequent analyses is non-negligible. We are not relying upon the magnitude of any given p-value to identify a single gene in the region as the most likely to explain the original evidence for linkage. Rather, we are suggesting that a set of genes be examined as likely candidate susceptibility loci for cardiovascular disease that is mediated by lipid levels.
In order to identify which gene or genes among the four we have selected contains variation for cardiovascular disease mediated by LDL cholesterol pathways, there are several methodologies available. Re-sequencing studies could be conducted in our sample, either in the entire population or by using individuals with extreme trait values (i.e., very high/low LDL-C levels or very early onset cardiovascular disease), as these data would capture all of the variation present in those samples and not rely upon common variants identified through a different, although ethnically similar, sample (i.e., CEPH Caucasians). In addition, those genes for which the biological function is known (i.e., EBF1) could have their level of activity or functionality directly assessed in genotyped samples. Such an approach can identify subsets of variation that appear to have functional consequences. However, due to LD within the variants, such results can still be ambiguous, in which case promoter and gene constructs can be created and assayed in the laboratory, allowing one to query the functional consequences of individual variants
In summary, we propose a strategy of parallel analysis where results from analyses of disease-related intermediate traits for a complex disease can be considered jointly with qualitative results from mapping of the disease trait itself, potentially enabling discovery of novel disease genes mediated through these intermediate phenotypes that might not have been identified using disease status alone. In addition, this strategy may allow the dissection of genetic heterogeneity mediated through the intermediate phenotype. We have applied this strategy to the fine mapping of a linkage peak for early-onset CAD and thereby have demonstrated replication of four genes within a region on chromosome 5q31. These genes, in particular, EBF1 given its potential biological plausibility, serve as novel candidate loci for cardiovascular disease and should be further evaluated.
World Health Organization. [http://www.who.int/research/en/]
American Heart Association. [http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/Conditions/Conditions_UCM_001087_SubHomePage.jsp]
Marenberg ME, Risch N, Berkman LF, Floderus B, de Faire U: Genetic susceptibility to death from coronary heart disease in a study of twins. N Engl J Med. 1994, 330 (15): 1041-1046.
Rissanen AM: Familial occurrence of coronary heart disease: effect of age at diagnosis. Am J Cardiol. 1979, 44 (1): 60-66.
Shea S, Ottman R, Gabrieli C, Stein Z, Nichols A: Family history as an independent risk factor for coronary artery disease. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1984, 4 (4): 793-801.
Helgadottir A, Thorleifsson G, Manolescu A, Gretarsdottir S, Blondal T, Jonasdottir A, Sigurdsson A, Baker A, Palsson A, Masson G, et al: A common variant on chromosome 9p21 affects the risk of myocardial infarction. Science. 2007, 316 (5830): 1491-1493.
Hauser ER, Crossman DC, Granger CB, Haines JL, Jones CJ, Mooser V, McAdam B, Winkelmann BR, Wiseman AH, Muhlestein JB, et al: A genomewide scan for early-onset coronary artery disease in 438 families: the GENECARD Study. Am J Hum Genet. 2004, 75 (3): 436-447.
Connelly JJ, Shah SH, Doss JF, Gadson S, Nelson S, Crosslin DR, Hale AB, Lou X, Wang T, Haynes C, et al: Genetic and functional association of FAM5C with myocardial infarction. BMC Med Genet. 2008, 9: 33-
Wang L, Hauser ER, Shah SH, Pericak-Vance MA, Haynes C, Crosslin D, Harris M, Nelson S, Hale AB, Granger CB, et al: Peakwide mapping on chromosome 3q13 identifies the kalirin gene as a novel candidate gene for coronary artery disease. Am J Hum Genet. 2007, 80 (4): 650-663.
Shah SH, Kraus WE, Crossman DC, Granger CB, Haines JL, Jones CJ, Mooser V, Huang L, Haynes C, Dowdy E, et al: Serum lipids in the GENECARD study of coronary artery disease identify quantitative trait loci and phenotypic subsets on chromosomes 3q and 5q. Ann Hum Genet. 2006, 70 (Pt 6): 738-748.
Williams SM, Haines JL: Correcting Away the Hidden Heritability. Annals of Human Genetics. 2011, no-no
Friedewald WT, Levy RI, Fredrickson DS: Estimation of the concentration of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol in plasma, without use of the preparative ultracentrifuge. Clin Chem. 1972, 18 (6): 499-502.
Otvos JD, Jeyarajah EJ, Bennett DW: Quantification of plasma lipoproteins by proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Clin Chem. 1991, 37 (3): 377-386.
Otvos JD, Jeyarajah EJ, Bennett DW, Krauss RM: Development of a proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic method for determining plasma lipoprotein concentrations and subspecies distributions from a single, rapid measurement. Clin Chem. 1992, 38 (9): 1632-1638.
Shah SH, Granger CB, Hauser ER, Kraus WE, Sun JL, Pieper K, Nelson CL, Delong ER, Califf RM, Newby LK: Reclassification of cardiovascular risk using integrated clinical and molecular biosignatures: Design of and rationale for the Measurement to Understand the Reclassification of Disease of Cabarrus and Kannapolis (MURDOCK) Horizon 1 Cardiovascular Disease Study. Am Heart J. 2010, 160 (3): 371-379 e372.
Seo D, Wang T, Dressman H, Herderick EE, Iversen ES, Dong C, Vata K, Milano CA, Rigat F, Pittman J, et al: Gene expression phenotypes of atherosclerosis. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2004, 24 (10): 1922-1927.
Cornhill JF, Herderick EE, Vince DG: The clinical morphology of human atherosclerotic lesions. Lessons from the PDAY Study. Pathobiological Determinants of Atherosclerosis in Youth. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 1995, 107 (18): 540-543.
Barrett JC: Haploview: Visualization and analysis of SNP genotype data. Cold Spring Harb Protoc. 2009, 2009 (10): pdb ip71
Lewis POaZ D: Genetic Data Analysis: Computer program for the analysis of allelic data Version 1.0. 2001
Wittke-Thompson JK, Pluzhnikov A, Cox NJ: Rational inferences about departures from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. Am J Hum Genet. 2005, 76 (6): 967-986.
Abecasis GR, Cardon LR, Cookson WO: A general test of association for quantitative traits in nuclear families. Am J Hum Genet. 2000, 66 (1): 279-292.
Fretz JA, Nelson T, Xi Y, Adams DJ, Rosen CJ, Horowitz MC: Altered metabolism and lipodystrophy in the early B-cell factor 1-deficient mouse. Endocrinology. 2010, 151 (4): 1611-1621.
O'Connell JR, Weeks DE: The VITESSE algorithm for rapid exact multilocus linkage analysis via genotype set-recoding and fuzzy inheritance. Nat Genet. 1995, 11 (4): 402-408.
Ott J: Linkage probability and its approximate confidence interval under possible heterogeneity. Genet Epidemiol Suppl. 1986, 1: 251-257.
Chung RH, Hauser ER, Martin ER: Interpretation of simultaneous linkage and family-based association tests in genome screens. Genet Epidemiol. 2007, 31 (2): 134-142.
Martin ER, Bass MP, Hauser ER, Kaplan NL: Accounting for linkage in family-based tests of association with missing parental genotypes. Am J Hum Genet. 2003, 73 (5): 1016-1026.
Liu J, Juo SH, Holopainen P, Terwilliger J, Tong X, Grunn A, Brito M, Green P, Mustalahti K, Maki M, et al: Genomewide linkage analysis of celiac disease in Finnish families. Am J Hum Genet. 2002, 70 (1): 51-59.
Postma DS, Bleecker ER, Amelung PJ, Holroyd KJ, Xu J, Panhuysen CI, Meyers DA, Levitt RC: Genetic susceptibility to asthma--bronchial hyperresponsiveness coinherited with a major gene for atopy. N Engl J Med. 1995, 333 (14): 894-900.
Sakai K, Shirasawa S, Ishikawa N, Ito K, Tamai H, Kuma K, Akamizu T, Tanimura M, Furugaki K, Yamamoto K, et al: Identification of susceptibility loci for autoimmune thyroid disease to 5q31-q33 and Hashimoto's thyroiditis to 8q23-q24 by multipoint affected sib-pair linkage analysis in Japanese. Hum Mol Genet. 2001, 10 (13): 1379-1386.
Samuelsson L, Enlund F, Torinsson A, Yhr M, Inerot A, Enerback C, Wahlstrom J, Swanbeck G, Martinsson T: A genome-wide search for genes predisposing to familial psoriasis by using a stratification approach. Hum Genet. 1999, 105 (6): 523-529.
Rioux JD, Daly MJ, Silverberg MS, Lindblad K, Steinhart H, Cohen Z, Delmonte T, Kocher K, Miller K, Guschwan S, et al: Genetic variation in the 5q31 cytokine gene cluster confers susceptibility to Crohn disease. Nat Genet. 2001, 29 (2): 223-228.
Friedrichs F, Zugck C, Rauch GJ, Ivandic B, Weichenhan D, Muller-Bardorff M, Meder B, El Mokhtari NE, Regitz-Zagrosek V, Hetzer R, et al: HBEGF, SRA1, and IK: Three cosegregating genes as determinants of cardiomyopathy. Genome Res. 2009, 19 (3): 395-403.
Yoneyama T, Kasuya H, Onda H, Akagawa H, Jinnai N, Nakajima T, Hori T, Inoue I: Association of positional and functional candidate genes FGF1, FBN2, and LOX on 5q31 with intracranial aneurysm. J Hum Genet. 2003, 48 (6): 309-314.
Walter JW, Blei F, Anderson JL, Orlow SJ, Speer MC, Marchuk DA: Genetic mapping of a novel familial form of infantile hemangioma. Am J Med Genet. 1999, 82 (1): 77-83.
Rankinen T, An P, Rice T, Sun G, Chagnon YC, Gagnon J, Leon AS, Skinner JS, Wilmore JH, Rao DC, et al: Genomic scan for exercise blood pressure in the Health, Risk Factors, Exercise Training and Genetics (HERITAGE) Family Study. Hypertension. 2001, 38 (1): 30-37.
Takami S, Wong ZY, Stebbing M, Harrap SB: Linkage analysis of glucocorticoid and beta2-adrenergic receptor genes with blood pressure and body mass index. Am J Physiol. 1999, 276 (4 Pt 2): H1379-1384.
Kooner JS, Chambers JC, Aguilar-Salinas CA, Hinds DA, Hyde CL, Warnes GR, Gomez Perez FJ, Frazer KA, Elliott P, Scott J, et al: Genome-wide scan identifies variation in MLXIPL associated with plasma triglycerides. Nat Genet. 2008, 40 (2): 149-151.
Teslovich TM, Musunuru K, Smith AV, Edmondson AC, Stylianou IM, Koseki M, Pirruccello JP, Ripatti S, Chasman DI, Willer CJ, et al: Biological, clinical and population relevance of 95 loci for blood lipids. Nature. 2010, 466 (7307): 707-713.
Waterworth DM, Ricketts SL, Song K, Chen L, Zhao JH, Ripatti S, Aulchenko YS, Zhang W, Yuan X, Lim N, et al: Genetic variants influencing circulating lipid levels and risk of coronary artery disease. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2010, 30 (11): 2264-2276.
Willer CJ, Sanna S, Jackson AU, Scuteri A, Bonnycastle LL, Clarke R, Heath SC, Timpson NJ, Najjar SS, Stringham HM, et al: Newly identified loci that influence lipid concentrations and risk of coronary artery disease. Nat Genet. 2008, 40 (2): 161-169.
Wain LV, Verwoert GC, O'Reilly PF, Shi G, Johnson T, Johnson AD, Bochud M, Rice KM, Henneman P, Smith AV, et al: Genome-wide association study identifies six new loci influencing pulse pressure and mean arterial pressure. Nat Genet. 2011, 43 (10): 1005-1011.
Ehret GB, Munroe PB, Rice KM, Bochud M, Johnson AD, Chasman DI, Smith AV, Tobin MD, Verwoert GC, Hwang SJ, et al: Genetic variants in novel pathways influence blood pressure and cardiovascular disease risk. Nature. 2011, 478 (7367): 103-109.
Lukin K, Fields S, Hartley J, Hagman J: Early B cell factor: Regulator of B lineage specification and commitment. Semin Immunol. 2008, 20 (4): 221-227.
Akerblad P, Lind U, Liberg D, Bamberg K, Sigvardsson M: Early B-cell factor (O/E-1) is a promoter of adipogenesis and involved in control of genes important for terminal adipocyte differentiation. Mol Cell Biol. 2002, 22 (22): 8015-8025.
Hesslein DG, Fretz JA, Xi Y, Nelson T, Zhou S, Lorenzo JA, Schatz DG, Horowitz MC: Ebf1-dependent control of the osteoblast and adipocyte lineages. Bone. 2009, 44 (4): 537-546.
Christin-Maitre S, Tachdjian G: Genome-wide association study and premature ovarian failure. Ann Endocrinol (Paris). 2010, 71 (3): 218-221.
Liu YZ, Guo YF, Wang L, Tan LJ, Liu XG, Pei YF, Yan H, Xiong DH, Deng FY, Yu N, et al: Genome-wide association analyses identify SPOCK as a key novel gene underlying age at menarche. PLoS Genet. 2009, 5 (3): e1000420-
Marr HS, Basalamah MA, Bouldin TW, Duncan AW, Edgell CJ: Distribution of testican expression in human brain. Cell Tissue Res. 2000, 302 (2): 139-144.
This work was supported by R01HL095987-01 (Shah), P01 HL73042 (Kraus, Goldschmidt-Clermont), RC2-HL101612 (Kraus), R01HL073389-01 (Hauser), the American Heart Association (FTF award, Shah), and a genotyping award through the National Heart Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI) funded Seattle SNPs project (http://pga.gs.washington.edu). We are grateful to all study participants in the GENECARD, CATHGEN and aorta studies.
DN performed the analysis, data interpretation, and authored the manuscript. BS performed genotyping, statistical analysis, data interpretation, and drafted part of the manuscript. CH performed analyses and informatics support. JJ performed analyses. JS performed analyses and informatics support. D Crosslin, D Crossman, MS, CG, DS, and PG performed phenotyping and contributed to the manuscript. WK contributed to the study design and the manuscript. SG contributed to study design and supervised the genotyping. EH contributed to study design and supervised the analysis. SS managed the chr 5. project, conceived of and contributed to the study design, performed phenotyping, supervised the analysis, interpreted the data, edited the manuscript, and is corresponding author. All authors have read and approved this manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: Genes associated with LDL cholesterol traits in the GENECARD study. This table displays minor allele frequencies (MAF), sample sizes, and p-values for the most significant SNPs associated with LDL cholesterol using the quantitative trait disequilibrium test (QTDT) in the GENECARD study. Note that the sample size is less than the overall GENECARD study sample size since not all families could be included due to lack of unaffecteds. SNPs within our four key candidate genes are in bold. (DOCX 15 KB)
Additional file 2: Genes associated with LDL cholesterol traits in the CATHGEN cohort. Displayed are the results for association of SNPs with LDLP levels in the CATHGEN sample. The significant SNPs are shown followed by the genic location, base pair position, and the corresponding p-value. SNPs within our four key candidate genes are presented in bold. (DOCX 22 KB)
Additional file 3: EBF1 SNPs with Leptin Levels. Six SNPs within and flanking EBF1 are listed with their Wilcoxon rank test p-values for association with leptin levels in CATHGEN in the total sample with available leptin levels, and stratified by race. (DOCX 15 KB)
Additional file 4: Association of SNPs with CAD in the GENECARD cohort. Displayed are results of the qualitative analysis using APL in the GENECARD sample. All significant SNPs are shown followed by their genic location, base pair position, and their corresponding p-values. Results within our four key candidate genes are displayed in bold. (DOCX 21 KB)
Additional file 5: Linkage results for SNPs with early-onset CAD in the GENECARD cohort. Displayed are linkage results for the GENECARD sample. All SNPs with two-point lod scores ≥ 1.5 are listed followed by their genic location, base pair position, individual lod score, and genetic model used. (DOCX 15 KB)
Additional file 6: Association of SNPs with CAD in the CATHGEN Cohort. Displayed are all significant results for the case-control analysis of SNPs with CAD in the CATHGEN sample. Each significant SNP is listed followed by their genic location, base pair, p-value, odds ratio, and 95% confidence interval for the genotypic and allelic models, respectively. (DOCX 46 KB)
Additional file 7: Association of SNPs with CAD for GENECARD proband vs. CATHGEN controls sample set. Displayed are the results of the GENECARD proband-CATHGEN control analysis, with all significant SNPs listed followed by their genic location, base pair position, p-value, odds ratio, and 95% confidence intervals for the genotypic and allelic models used. (DOCX 35 KB)
Additional file 8: Association of SNPs with Degree of Atherosclerosis in the Aorta Samples. Displayed are results of association of SNPs with degree of atherosclerosis in the aorta samples, with each significant SNP listed followed by their genic position, base pair position, p-value, odds ratio, and 95% confidence interval for the genotypic and allelic models. (DOCX 46 KB)
About this article
Cite this article
Nolan, D.K., Sutton, B., Haynes, C. et al. Fine mapping of a linkage peak with integration of lipid traits identifies novel coronary artery disease genes on chromosome 5. BMC Genet 13, 12 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2156-13-12
- Cardiovascular Disease
- Positional Cloning
- Intermediate Phenotype
- Fine Mapping